For Sale

$1,199,900

For sale

58 Gr••••• Ave (Sign up for 50 free credits to unlock)Staten Island, NY 10312

4Beds

4Baths

2,350Sq Ft Living

4,000Sq Ft Lot

1970Year Built

Property Description

THE ONE YOU'VE BEEN WAITING FOR-TRULY AN UNMATCHED OPPORTUNITY! LET'S BREAK IT DOWN: 1. LOCATION - SPECTACULAR ANNADALE PRIVATE RETREAT: nestled on a serene, tree-lined block surrounded by pristine natural beauty just across the street! Enjoy complete privacy, peaceful surroundings, and picturesque views every day. 2. INCOME-GENERATING 1 BEDROOM RENTAL: this incredible property includes a charming first-floor rental unit, perfect for generating extra income. 3. YARD - RESORT-STYLE OUTDOOR OASIS: come outside into your personal paradise featuring a stunning inground saltwater heated pool (new liner in 2025), complemented by elegant pavers and a stylish cabana-The beautifully back yard creates a private, tranquil environment that feels like your own resort - HOME FEATURES INCLUDE: Brand-new 2025 kitchen boasts an open-concept layout with modern appliances, stylish cabinetry, and seamless connectivity to the dining and living areas-all 4 bathrooms have been thoughtfully updated with contemporary fixtures and finishes, providing comfort and style. Gorgeous hardwood floors flow throughout the entire home, New A/C central Air. New Baseboard Heating. Roof with Solar Panels done in 2011. Start scheduling your appiotments today!

Property Facts & Features

Property Type: Multi Family
Status: For Sale
Listed: Aug 8, 2026
Price per Sq Ft: $511/sqft
ZIP Code: 10312
Full Baths: 2
Half Baths: 1
Stories: 2
Garage: 4 spaces
Parking: 4 Spaces, Built In Garage, Private Drive
Cooling: 5+, AC Units: 5+
Construction: Wood Frame
Property Tax (2025): $10,135/yr
Assessed Value: $61,680
Last Sold: $540,000 · Feb 1, 2011
Neighborhood: Annadale
County: Richmond
School District: New York City Geographic District #31

Estimated Value

$1,147,300Range $941,286 to $1,411,929

Automated estimate. Not an appraisal.

Features & Amenities

Bedrooms

Bedrooms: 4

Bathrooms

Total Bathrooms: 4.00
Full Bathrooms: 2
1/2 Bathrooms: 1
3/4 Bathrooms: 1
Bathrooms On Level 1: 3.00
Bathrooms On Level 2: 1.00

Land Info

Lot Size Acres: 0.0918274
Lot Size Square Feet: 4000

Utilities

Electric: 200 Amp

Other Rooms

Total Rooms: 10
Basement Features: Finished, Full

Multi-Unit Info

Number of Units: 2
Bedrooms in Unit-1: 1
Bedrooms in Unit-2: 3
Total Bathrooms in Unit-1: 1
Total Bathrooms in Unit-2: 3
Full Bathrooms in Unit-1: 1
Full Bathrooms in Unit-2: 1
Half Bathrooms in Unit-2: 1
Total Rooms in Unit-1: 3
Total Rooms in Unit-2: 7
Unit-1 Description: 1 Bedroom
Unit-2 Description: 3 Bedrooms
Unit-1 Furnished Description: Oven/Range
Unit 1 Total Actual Rent: 1600

Interior Features

A/C Unit - Wall
Central Air
Dryer
Garage Door Opener(s)
Laundry Area
Microwave
Patio Garden
Pool
Refrigerator
Stove
Terrace
Washer
Flooring: Hardwood

Garage and Parking

Garage Spaces: 4
Parking Features: 4 Spaces, Built-In Garage, Private Drive

Heating and Cooling

Cooling Features: 5+, AC Units: 5+
Heating Fuel: Gas
Water Heaters: Gas, Hot Water Coil in Boiler

Other Property Info

Annual Tax Amount: 10135
Source Listing Status: Pending
County: Staten Island
Cross Street: Annadale Rd
Area: Annadale
Source Neighborhood: Annadale
Zoning: R3A
Property Subtype: Multi-Family

Building and Construction

Total Square Feet Living: 2350
Year Built: 1970
Building Area Total: 1175
Building Exterior Type: Stone, Vinyl Siding
Construction Materials: Wood Frame
Foundation Details: Poured Concrete
Property Age: 56
Roof: Shingle
Levels or Stories: 2
Structure Type: Detached
House Style: High Ranch

Exterior and Lot Features

Yard: Back,Front,Side

Price & Event History

Date	Event	Price	$/Sq Ft
Aug 8, 2026	Listed	$1,199,900	$511
Aug 2, 2026	Listed	$1,199,900	$511
Jun 29, 2026	Listing removed	$829,888	-
Mar 5, 2020	Sold	$815,000	$347
Dec 23, 2019	Listing removed	$898,888	$410
Dec 18, 2019	Listing removed	$569,000	$260
Apr 23, 2019	Price Changed	$875,000	$372
Mar 26, 2019	Listed	$878,000	$374
Sep 3, 2018	Listing removed	$898,888	$410
Aug 21, 2018	Listed	$898,888	$410
Jan 17, 2011	Sold	$540,000	$246
Oct 7, 2010	Price Changed	$559,000	$255
Aug 26, 2010	Listed	$569,000	$260
Feb 13, 2009	Listing removed	$569,000	$260
Sep 2, 2008	Listed	$589,000	$269

Property Tax History

Year	Tax	Assessed	Land	Building	Market
2025	$10,135	$61,680	$13,020	$48,660	$1,028,000
2024	$9,561	$57,840	$13,020	$44,820	$964,000
2023	$9,427	$53,940	$13,020	$40,920	$899,000
2022	$8,742	$43,860	$13,020	$30,840	$731,000
2021	$9,015	$42,840	$13,020	$29,820	$714,000
2020	$8,901	$44,820	$13,020	$31,800	$747,000
2019	$7,640	$48,660	$13,020	$35,640	$811,000
2018	$7,433	$38,683	$10,762	$27,921	$780,000
2017	$6,793	$36,494	$12,221	$24,273	$648,000
2016	$6,618	$36,216	$11,943	$24,273	$658,000
2015	$6,231	$35,043	$10,036	$25,007	$632,000
2014	$5,724	$33,060	$10,860	$22,200	$551,000

Nearby Schools

8/10
Ps 36 J C Drumgoole
Public · Elementary · Grades K-5
0.5 mi
7/10
Tottenville High School
Public · High · Grades 9-12
1.6 mi
9/10
Is 7 Elias Bernstein
Public · Middle · Grades 6-8
1.8 mi
NR
Eltingville Lutheran School
Private · Elementary, Middle · Grades PK-7
0.6 mi