Active

$499,999

For sale

440 Pr••••• Ave (Sign up for 50 free credits to unlock)Piscataway, NJ 08854

3Beds

2Baths

2,124Sq Ft Living

7,349Sq Ft Lot

1914Year Built

Property Description

Opportunity Knocks In Piscataway! Bring your vision and unlock the potential of 440 Prospect Avenue. This 3-bedroom, 2-full-bath fixer-upper offers a great opportunity for homeowners, investors, contractors, or renovation buyers looking to create something of their own. The first floor features a primary bedroom and full bathroom, offering the convenience of first-floor living. Upstairs you'll find two additional bedrooms and a second full bathroom. A large basement provides additional space and plenty of possibilities. Situated on an approximately 49' x 150' lot, the property also features a detached two-car garage, above-ground pool, and generous outdoor space. Whether you're searching for a fixer upper, renovation project, investment property, value-add opportunity, rehab, or a home you can customize, this property is ready for its next chapter. Convenient Piscataway location near major highways, shopping, dining, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, and area amenities. Property is being sold strictly AS-IS. Buyer responsible for all due diligence, inspections, repairs, certifications, and verifying property information. Bring your ideas and imagine the possibilities!

Property Facts & Features

Property Type: Single Family
Status: Active
Listed: Sep 16, 2026
Price per Sq Ft: $235/sqft
ZIP Code: 08854
Full Baths: 2
Stories: 2
Garage: 2 spaces
Parking: 2 Car Width, Garage, Detached
Heating: Baseboard Hotwater
Cooling: Ceiling Fan(S), Window Unit(S)
Construction: Vinyl Siding
Style: Cape Cod
Property Tax (2025): $8,657/yr
Assessed Value: $548,100
Last Sold: $371,900 · Jun 15, 2006
County: Middlesex
School District: Piscataway Township School District

Estimated Value

$510,723Range $415,800 to $595,100

Automated estimate. Not an appraisal.

Features & Amenities

Bedrooms

Bedrooms: 3
Primary Bedroom Level: First
Primary Bedroom Features: 1st Floor

Bathrooms

Total Bathrooms: 2
Full Bathrooms: 2

Land Info

Lot Description: Corner Lot
Lot Size Acres: 0.1687098
Lot Size Dimensions: 150.00 x 0.00
Lot Size Square Feet: 7349

Utilities

Gas: Natural Gas
Sewer: Public Sewer
Natural Gas Connected
Water Source: Public

Appliances

Dishwasher
Dryer
Gas Range/Oven
Washer

Other Rooms

Total Rooms: 10
Basement Description: Full, Storage Space

Interior Features

1 Bedroom
Kitchen
Living Room
Bath Full
Den
Dining Room
2 Bedrooms
Flooring: Parquet, Vinyl-Linoleum

Garage and Parking

Covered Spaces: 2
Garage Spaces: 2
Open Parking: Yes
Parking Features: 2 Car Width, Garage, Detached

Kitchen and Dining

Dining Room Features: Formal Dining Room
Kitchen Features: Separate Dining Area

School Information

Elementary School District: Piscataway Township School Dis
High School District: Piscataway Township School Dis
Middle or Junior School District: Piscataway Township School Dis

Heating and Cooling

Cooling Features: Ceiling Fan(s), Window Unit(s)
Heating Features: Baseboard Hotwater
Heating: Yes
Ceiling Fans: Yes

Other Property Info

Annual Tax Amount: 8657
Source Listing Status: Active
County: Middlesex
Tax Year: 2025
Ownership: Fee Simple
Exclusions: Personal Property
Home Warranty: No
Source Neighborhood: Piscataway
Parcel Number: 170100600000000101
Postal Code Plus 4: 1454
Subdivision: Piscataway
Zoning: R75
Property Subtype: Single Family Residence

Building and Construction

Total Square Feet Living: 2124
Year Built: 1914
Building Area Total: 2124
Building Area Units: Square Feet
Common Walls: 2 Levels, Cape Cod
Construction Materials: Vinyl Siding
Foundation Details: Full, Garage, Basement
Levels: Two
Living Area Units: Square Feet
Property Age: 112
Roof: Asphalt
Levels or Stories: 2
Building Total Stories: 2
Architectural Style: Cape Cod

Price & Event History

Date	Event	Price	$/Sq Ft
Sep 16, 2026	Listed	$499,999	$235
Sep 15, 2026	Listed	$499,999	-
Jun 15, 2006	Sold	$371,900	$181
Jun 17, 1987	Sold	$153,500	$75
Aug 31, 1982	Sold	$21,000	$10

Property Tax History

Year	Tax	Assessed	Land	Building	Market
2025	$8,657	$548,100	$309,600	$238,500	$560,200
2024	$8,121	$486,900	$280,500	$206,400	$496,888
2023	$8,067	$390,500	$181,000	$209,500	$414,456
2022	$7,946	$357,000	$181,000	$176,000	$384,905
2021	$7,147	$308,500	$151,000	$157,500	$321,220
2020	$6,901	$298,500	$143,500	$155,000	$319,285
2019	$7,023	$298,500	$143,500	$155,000	$318,672
2018	$6,777	$289,400	$143,500	$145,900	$273,976
2017	$6,525	$240,700	$108,500	$132,200	$266,203
2016	$6,407	$240,700	$108,500	$132,200	$266,349
2015	$6,311	$240,700	$108,500	$132,200	$247,583
2014	$6,171	$240,700	$108,500	$132,200	$240,052

Nearby Schools

6/10
Quibbletown Middle School
Public · Middle · Grades 6-8
0.8 mi
6/10
Arbor Elementary School
Public · Elementary · Grades 4-5
1.1 mi
6/10
Piscataway Twp High School
Public · High · Grades 9-12
2.4 mi
NR
Our Lady of Fatima School
Private · Elementary, Middle · Grades K-8
0.2 mi